Français
Graphic
Friday 19 February 2016

UK cities react against the government attack on their freedom to divest

Several UK cities, including Energy Cities’ member Milton Keynes, have spoken up against controversial plans from the national government to put restrictions on their freedom to divest from fossil fuels. Once again local leadership is being hampered by obstacles from the national level. A situation which reminds us of the not-so-distant case of the city of Vaxjo’s ambitious sustainable energy legislation being challenged by the Swedish competition authority.

An attack on democracy

UK councils were recently warned by the national government that they will face “’severe penalties’ if they divest from fossil fuel holdings or boycott oil, coal or gas firms in procurement tenders” the Guardian revealed. This decision is difficult to understand a few months only after the British government committed to reduce greenhouse gas emissions to net zero later this century during the COP21 in Paris. Even more incomprehensible is the ’protection of UK taxpayers’ argument used to justify the measure as fossil fuel investments have recently been labelled a “stranded asset” risk by the governor of the Bank of England.

The council leader of Milton Keynes, member of Energy Cities, called the announcement an “undemocratic attack on the renewable energy sector”. “If local councillors wish to choose other investments, such as green energy that are in the longer term interest of society, then they should be free to do so”, he added.
Several British cities including Energy Cities’ member Bristol have already joined the divest movement. Local governments need more room to act and drive the energy transition rather than undemocratic restrictions aimed at preserving an unsustainable model.

Divest for dummies

The fossil fuel divestment movement started a few years ago and is growing stronger and stronger thanks to the momentum created by the COP21. Numerous investment funds, universities and city councils have already committed to withdraw their money from fossil fuel related investments. Two main arguments back these decisions. First, divestment acts as a disincentive for fossil fuel companies to invest in new projects. This is essential to meet the 2°C climate target the international community agreed upon. Second, there is a financial argument based on the recent climate agreements. Fossil fuel related investment are risky assets as they will become worthless when the climate targets are met.



by Rémi Collombet-Gourdon on 19 February 2016 / 410 visits




Related articles for Financing & Economy / Financement & Economie

The Udine Climate Fund: another step towards a sustainable energy city
by Béatrice Alcaraz, Jana Cicmanova on 23 May 2016 /


#Bornova2016 - Remunicipalising energy services: why and how?
by Floriane Cappelletti on 6 May 2016 /


Marché européen de quotas d'émissions : Nos 5 recommandations pour une utilisation judicieuse du "Fonds de Modernisation'
by Béatrice Alcaraz, David Donnerer on 19 avril 2016 /


A Stuttgart, les propriétaires de maisons individuelles peuvent bénéficier d'un pack rénovation "clé-en-main"
by Floriane Cappelletti on 31 mars 2016 /


In Stuttgart, private home owners can enjoy 'care-free' energy renovation package
by Floriane Cappelletti on 31 March 2016 /


Energy-renovation of houses : In Bordeaux Metropole, 85% of households fit requirements for a dedicated bank loan !
by Floriane Cappelletti on 17 March 2016 /


Rénovation énergétique du secteur résidentiel : à Bordeaux Métropole, 85% des foyers sont éligibles pour un prêt dédié !
by Floriane Cappelletti on 17 mars 2016 /


UK cities react against the government attack on their freedom to divest
by Rémi Collombet-Gourdon on 19 February 2016 /


La ville portugaise d'Águeda crée un Fonds local pour l'Efficacité Energétique et la Gestion de l'Eau
by Floriane Cappelletti on 11 février 2016 /


Portuguese city of Águeda sets up a local Fund for Energy and Water Efficiency
by Jana Cicmanova on 11 February 2016 /


Koprivnica crée le premier fonds renouvelable pour l'énergie de Croatie
by Floriane Cappelletti on 28 janvier 2016 /


Croatia's first local energy revolving fund is in Koprivnica!
by Jana Cicmanova on 28 January 2016 /


Frederikshavn, Danemark : Mobiliser l'épargne qui "dort" sur les comptes en banque des citoyens
by Floriane Cappelletti on 13 janvier 2016 /


Frederikshavn, Denmark: Mobilising savings ‘sleeping’ on citizens’ bank accounts
by Jana Cicmanova on 13 January 2016 /


Encourager les investissements au niveau local : analyse de projets ELENA-BEI dans Paris, Malmö, Barcelone, Bristol et la Région Bruxelles-Capitale
by Floriane Cappelletti on 8 juillet 2015 /


Unlocking investments in cities: Review of ELENA-EIB projects in Barcelona, Bristol, Malmö, Paris and Brussels-Capital Region
by Floriane Cappelletti on 8 July 2015 /


Financer l’énergie durable : comment s’y retrouver dans le labyrinthe européen
by Béatrice Alcaraz on 23 juin 2015 /


Financing sustainable energy: Finding your way
by Béatrice Alcaraz on 23 June 2015 /


La transition énergétique, véritable cocktail vitaminé pour l’économie locale !
by Floriane Cappelletti on 18 juin 2015 /


Energy transition, a true vitamin cocktail for the local economy!
by Floriane Cappelletti on 18 June 2015 /


Villes résilientes #3 : Développer de nouvelles approches financières
by Floriane Cappelletti on 1er juin 2015 /


Resilient cities #3: Developing new financing approaches
by Floriane Cappelletti on 1 June 2015 /


La BEI devrait accorder plus d'importance à l'efficacité énergétique et aux renouvelables au niveau local
by Floriane Cappelletti on 23 mars 2015 /


EIB should increase its focus on energy efficiency and renewables at local level
by Admin on 19 mars 2015 /


Le rapport de l'EEFIG identifie des moyens d'augmenter les investissements dans l'efficacité énergétique
by Floriane Cappelletti on 28 février 2015 /


EEFIG report identifies ways to drive new finance for energy efficiency investments
by Floriane Cappelletti on 27 February 2015 /


Le nouveau guide de la Convention des Maires aide les villes à identifier des opportunités de financement de leurs projets d'énergie durable
by Floriane Cappelletti on 5 février 2015 /


New Covenant of Mayors guide helps cities identify suitable funding opportunities for sustainable energy
by Floriane Cappelletti on 5 February 2015 /


Economic impact of the local energy transition - Energy Cities issues one-of-a-kind study
by Floriane Cappelletti on 22 December 2014 /


Impact économique de la transition énergétique locale - Energy Cities publie une étude unique en son genre
by Floriane Cappelletti on 22 décembre 2014 /


Le nouveau Plan d'Investissement de la Commission devrait générer 350 milliards d'euros d'investissements. Quelles opportunités pour les villes ?
by Floriane Cappelletti on 9 décembre 2014 /




Related articles for Governance / Gouvernance

New dialogues between cities & local stakeholders
by Blandine Pidoux on 10 mai 2016 /


Une plateforme innovante pour atteindre les objectifs énergie-climat d'ici à 2020
by Rémi Collombet-Gourdon on 29 avril 2016 /


An innovative platform to achieve the 2020 climate and energy targets
by Rémi Collombet-Gourdon on 28 April 2016 /


Edito politique : Au croisement des chemins ?
by Claire Roumet on 4 avril 2016 /


Policy brief: At the crossroads?
by Claire Roumet on 4 April 2016 /


Thessalonique (Grèce) et Bottrop (Allemagne), ensemble dans l'initiative "Municipalités pour une Europe forte"
by Blandine Pidoux on 9 mars 2016 /


Thessaloniki (GR) and Bottrop (DE), together in the "Municipalities for a strong Europe" Initiative
by Blandine Pidoux on 9 March 2016 /


UK cities react against the government attack on their freedom to divest
by Rémi Collombet-Gourdon on 19 February 2016 /


Transition énergétique : les nouveaux dialogues villes - acteurs du territoire
by Blandine Pidoux on 21 janvier 2016 /


La ville de Parme encourage ses citoyens à entreprendre des travaux de rénovation énergétique
by Floriane Cappelletti on 17 décembre 2015 /


La gouvernance locale de A à Z : Energy Cities publie son Glossaire positif de la transition énergétique lors de la COP21
by Floriane Cappelletti on 4 décembre 2015 /


Local governance from A to Z: Energy Cities releases Positive Glossary of the Energy Transition during COP21
by Floriane Cappelletti on 4 December 2015 /


Victory for local energy! Swedish municipality of Växjö wins case against competition authority
by Floriane Cappelletti on 30 November 2015 /


Victoire pour l'énergie locale ! La justice donne raison à la ville suédoise de Växjö face à l'autorité nationale de la concurrence
by Floriane Cappelletti on 27 novembre 2015 /


Energy Cities rejoint la Campagne "1 000 entreprises de l'ESS pour le climat"
by Béatrice Alcaraz, Sylvie Lacassagne on 17 novembre 2015 /


Local elected leaders urge European Commission to reshape energy governance architecture
by Alix Bolle on 16 November 2015 /


Bielsko-Biala : Where Poland shows that "low-carbon" is possible
by Miriam Eisermann on 12 November 2015 /


Bielsko-Biala : pour une Pologne à faible intensité carbone
by Miriam Eisermann on 12 novembre 2015 /


Planification urbaine : l'intelligence collective en action à Helsinki
by Blandine Pidoux on 29 octobre 2015 /


Group intelligence in Helsinki: collaborative sustainable city planning
by Floriane Cappelletti on 29 octobre 2015 /


Agenda Smart Cities: encourageons une transition énergétique basée sur les villes et leurs citoyens !
by Floriane Cappelletti on 21 septembre 2015 /


Les messages des acteurs non-étatiques aux négociateurs de la COP21 : Donner les capacités d'action aux gouvernements locaux et désinvestir des énergies fossiles !
by Floriane Cappelletti on 3 juillet 2015 /


Non-state players’ message to COP21 negotiators: Empowering sub-national governments and divesting from fossil fuels
by Floriane Cappelletti on 3 July 2015 /


Epernay and Ettlingen: A successful TANDEM for the local energy transition
by Floriane Cappelletti on 11 June 2015 /


Epernay et Ettlingen : TANDEM gagnant pour la transition énergétique locale
by Floriane Cappelletti on 11 juin 2015 /


Décentralisation, dévolution... Révolution !
by Béatrice Alcaraz on 4 juin 2015 /


Decentralisation, devolution... Revolution!
by Béatrice Alcaraz on 4 June 2015 /


Energy Cities members commit to city-to-city cooperation as a key tool for the energy transition
by Floriane Cappelletti on 29 mai 2015 /


Les membres d'Energy Cities s'engagent pour la coopération entre villes, outil clé de la transition énergétique
by Floriane Cappelletti on 29 mai 2015 /


Resilient cities #1: Developing new forms of governance
by Béatrice Alcaraz on 11 May 2015 /


Villes résilientes #1 : développer de nouvelles formes de gouvernance
by Béatrice Alcaraz on 11 mai 2015 /


TANDEM : des couples franco-allemands pour la transition énergétique
by Blandine Pidoux on 13 avril 2015 /


Växjö urges Swedish Government to become the world’s first fossil-fuel free nation
by Miriam Eisermann on 25 March 2015 /


L'Union de l'énergie ne peut pas fonctionner sans les villes et les citoyens
by Floriane Cappelletti on 26 février 2015 /


Energy Union – It can’t work without cities and citizens
by Floriane Cappelletti on 26 February 2015 /


Dans les coulisses d'une transition énergétique réussie - Nouvelle publication d'Energy Cities
by Floriane Cappelletti on 3 février 2015 /


"No energy transition without citizens" - Interview with Energy Cities' Executive Director Claire Roumet
by Floriane Cappelletti on 30 January 2015 /


European Green Capital Bristol (UK) highlights the importance of its Energy Service
by Béatrice Alcaraz on 18 December 2014 /


Plein feu sur Tampere (Finlande)
by Béatrice Alcaraz on 16 décembre 2014 /




The team

Blog Categories
Line
Last posts
Line
Archives
separator
You are here: Energy Cities > English > BLOG

ABOUT
Association
Board of Directors
Members
Team
Job Offer
Internships
Come and meet us
POSITION PAPERS
JOIN
How to join
Why we joined
ACTIONS
COP21 and beyond
Initiatives & Campaigns
Projects
Past projects
Workshops
Webinars
Annual Conference
Study Tours
RESOURCES
Energy transition: our proposals
Best practices from members
Publications
e-libraries
EC INFO Magazine
Newsletter
BLOG
MEDIA
Press releases
Articles
Communication tools

 
Addresses Energy Cities - Besançon Energy Cities - Bruxelles